
Physicians spreading COVID-19 misinformation on social media, despite being a minority, have a significant impact due to their respected status. While vaccine misinformation is prevalent among them, the lack of formal regulations makes tackling this issue challenging. A recent study explored the dissemination of false claims by 52 physicians across various platforms, underscoring concerns about the persistence of medical misinformation. Nearly 75% of doctors acknowledge the problem, highlighting the need for consequences, including warnings and license revocation.
Emerging data highlights the extent to which medical misinformation related to COVID-19 has been propagated by physicians through social media platforms. Though the number of doctors involved in spreading such misinformation remains limited, recent findings focused on COVID-19-related falsehoods underscore that these providers have managed to garner significant visibility for their inaccurate assertions.
This broad influence presents a concern, especially considering the significant trust reposed in physicians as purveyors of public health information on social media platforms, as emphasized by researchers from the University of Massachusetts Amherst.
The Age of COVID-19: A Time of Doubt and Diverse Adherence
The COVID-19 pandemic was characterized by skepticism and varying degrees of compliance with preventive public health measures, including mask-wearing and vaccination. This skepticism stemmed from multiple factors, outlined by researchers in JAMA Network Open, with medical misinformation emerging as a prominent contributor.
Separate evaluations have identified medical misinformation as a significant driver of vaccine hesitancy during the pandemic.
The Potentially Detrimental Role of Physicians in Spreading Misinformation
Highlighting the introduction of their JAMA study, the researchers assert that COVID-19 misinformation proliferated across various individuals on social media platforms. Nonetheless, misinformation perpetuated by physicians could be especially damaging due to their standing as credible sources of medical and public health information, amplifying the potential negative repercussions.
Fortunately, the study found that instances of physician-originated misinformation were infrequent, with only a small subset of physicians contributing to its dissemination.
Analyzing Misinformation Propagation on Social Media and News Outlets
Examining prominent social media platforms (Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, Parler, and YouTube), alongside reputable news sources (The New York Times and NPR), the researchers conducted an exploration of medical misinformation propagated by physicians between January 2021 and December 2022.
Across a diverse range of medical specialties, 52 physicians were identified as disseminating medical misinformation, spanning the entirety of the United States. This misinformation revolved around several central themes, including vaccines, medications, masks, and conspiracy theories.
Vaccine Misinformation Takes Center Stage
The most prevalent form of medical misinformation propagated by physicians was vaccine-related, with a staggering 80 percent of implicated doctors promoting false assertions about the inefficacy of COVID-19 vaccines.
Additionally, approximately 53.8 percent of physicians espoused conspiracy theories, while 51.9 percent made inaccurate statements regarding treatments. Notably, three-quarters of the physicians contributed misinformation across multiple categories.
Physician’s Role in Public Health Messaging
Comparing physicians’ propagated misinformation to other forms, the researchers noted similarities. However, the distinct role physicians hold in public health messaging due to their trusted guidance for patients underscores the significance of addressing this issue.
At the outset of vaccine distribution, surveys indicated that physicians were the most trusted sources for vaccine information. While they were seen as pivotal in promoting vaccine access, physicians spreading vaccine misinformation had an adverse effect.
Dissemination and Impact of Misinformation
The study revealed that instances of medical misinformation by physicians managed to attain some level of outreach. Approximately 38.5 percent of physicians posted misinformation across five or more platforms.
Twitter emerged as the preferred communication platform, with 71.2 percent of involved physicians employing this channel for spreading medical misinformation. The median follower count of 67,400 reflects a substantial scope of influence.
Addressing Physician-Spread Medical Misinformation
While the research offers a valuable step forward in comprehending the propagation of medical misinformation by physicians, the authors admit that eradicating this practice faces significant obstacles. Calls from entities such as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) and the American Medical Association (AMA) to curb medical misinformation lack a concrete regulatory framework.
Limiting Factors and Recommendations
The researchers attribute the persistence of misinformation to factors such as the limited resources available to licensing boards for monitoring the internet and the jurisdictional challenges faced by state government officials seeking to regulate physician-propagated misinformation.
Perceptions and Responses within the Medical Community
It’s crucial to note that a substantial number of physicians express concern about the proliferation of medical misinformation online, regardless of the source.
A survey conducted on behalf of the de Beaumont Foundation in April 2023 found that 75 percent of doctors consider medical misinformation a significant issue. This misinformation spillage is affecting clinical settings, with 44 percent of physicians reporting that half the information brought in by patients is false.
A Call for Accountability
Within this context, more than 75 percent of physicians feel responsible, along with their colleagues, for counteracting medical misinformation. This pertains to COVID-19 transmission, vaccine safety and efficacy, other vaccines, off-label usage of drugs like hydroxychloroquine for COVID-19, and the effectiveness of masks.
Regarding physicians who disseminate medical misinformation, respondents to the de Beaumont Foundation’s poll advocate consequences: 85 percent favor a warning for the first offense, 73 percent support fines for a second offense, 70 percent agree with a temporary suspension of license for a third offense, and 63 percent concur with a permanent revocation of license for a fourth offense.